Teacher's Guide Bears 2000 and Beyond - Glossary


Activity 3 - What’s Wrong With This Picture?

Level

All
Note: Have lots of fun with this one but be prepared to wind it up with a serious discussion on appropriate human and bear behaviour.

Purpose
  • To explore issues surrounding bear habituation
  • To learn the difference between appropriate and inappropriate behaviour towards bears
  • To illustrate the changes in human attitudes and actions towards bears over time
Materials
  • 4 images below: What’s Wrong with this Picture?  
      
  • Procedure

    Discussion of slide images 

    Uninvited bears at a picnic, Jasper Park Lodge1. Show first image
    Uninvited black bears at a picnic, Jasper Park Lodge, ca. 1960s, Postcard, Grant-Mann Lithographics Ltd. Vancouver

    a) Use this first image as a warm-up for the ones to follow.
    Are following statements true or false? (Answers in italics)
    T    F   These bears have proper table manners.
    T    F    Wild bears have interrupted someone’s coffee break.
    T    F   Any food is good food to a bear.
    T    F   The bears are really concerned that someone is taking their picture at close range.
    T    F     People should be able to leave food outside without
    consequences. 
    T    F    If bears learn to associate the smell of humans with food, they will search for food in places where there are people.

    b) What do you think is wrong with this picture?

    c) Message: A human fed bear is a dead bear (unless it lives in the zoo!)


    Black bear in driver's seat of car, 19402. Image: Black bear in driver’s seat, ca. 1940, Postcard # 1023, Byron Harmon, Banff, Canada

    a)  Discussion points:

    • Under what circumstance might a bear get into a car?
    • What do you think will happen next?
    • Do you think this picture was taken recently? Why/why not?
    • Do you think a situation like this would take place in the present day? Why/why not?

    b)  Message:

    • This bear was likely coaxed into position with food treats from people. Bears that become accustomed to people food often seek it out over and above natural food sources.
    • Feeding bears at the roadside was common many years ago, before the harmful effects of this practice were fully realized. Today, for the safety of humans and animals, it is illegal to feed wildlife in Canada’s national parks.


    Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep beside the highway 3. Image: Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep beside the highway, Colleen Campbell, Canmore, Canada

    a)

    • Why have the people stopped their cars here?
    • Why are the sheep on the side of the road?
    • Is it safe for the people to be out of their cars?

    b) 

    • What traffic rules have been broken by the driver of the red car?
    • Is it safe to be parked on or near a curve in the road? (The driver of the red car has crossed over solid and dashed lines, parking the car on the wrong side of the highway, in the driving lane, facing on-coming traffic. Both cars are parked dangerously near a curve.)

    c)

    • Do the sheep appear to be bothered by the people standing nearby? Do you think the sheep have become accustomed to seeing people? Is this a good thing?
    • Bears sometimes graze at the side of the road, like these sheep. What do drivers often do when they see a bear at the side of the road? Would you get out of your car if you saw a bear at the side of the road?
    • Do you think bears would be as tolerant of people as these sheep are?

    d) 

    • Message: Many wild animals graze beside highways at certain times of the year. Bears need certain kinds of food at certain times of the year to survive. They sometimes find what they need right next to the highway and may react aggressively if interrupted while eating. 
    • All wild animals can be dangerous and people have been hurt by aggressive sheep and deer. Keep the wild in wildlife, stay in your car.


    Captain Conrad O'Brien-ffrench4.  Image: Captain Conrad O’Brien-ffrench and bear at Banff nuisance grounds. Photographer, Rosalie ffrench. Archives, Whyte Museum of the Canadian Rockies

    a)

    • What appears to be happening in this picture?
    • Is it safe for the man to be so close to the bear?

    b)

    • Why is there smoke in this picture?
    • What are ‘nuisance grounds”?
    • Do you think this picture was taken recently? Why?

    c)

    • Message: This photograph was taken at the Banff dump or “nuisance grounds” as they used to be called, many years ago.  People took garbage there, then it was burned, hence the smoke.
    • Mr. O’Brien-ffrench lived nearby and was probably very familiar with the bears that visited the dump. Because of the abundance of food at the dump, the bear in the picture had plenty to eat and was likely quite tolerant of people and other animals.
    • Attitudes regarding the acceptable behaviour of people and wild animals have changed a great deal since this photograph was taken. We now know that when wild animals feed at dumps, they become dependent on them as a source of food and lose their natural fear of humans. They often seek other sources of people food, and may become aggressive in order to get it. There are no longer garbage dumps in Banff National Park. Instead, Banff’s garbage is taken to Calgary for disposal.
    • It is never safe to approach a bear like the man in the picture.
    Evaluation
    • Demonstrated understanding of key concepts regarding bear habituation
    • Knowledge of appropriate behaviour to ensure habituation does not occur
    Curriculum Connections

    Social Studies; Environmental Science

    IntroductionActivitiesGlossaryGuided Program
    Whyte Museum – Bears: 2000 and Beyond Teacher's Guide